Stud or Dud

[Delandis]

I know this could have easily gone into the draft section and we're not done with the draft yet, but I didn't want it to get lost in the shuffle so that I could look back at it further down the line.

How about this, everyone pick 4 players. Two from picks 1.1-2.32(two duds), and two from anywhere after that(two studs). Predict who will be a stud or a dud. Just a little something to pass the time.


For me,

Duds:
1.5-Marlon Madison, QB
1.28-Les Pagnotti, DE

Studs:
3.11-Peter Sigler, TE
3.28-Glen Leighton, WR

[Acid]

1.19 QB Dixon Arseneault
2.20 FL Phil Alston

3.1 DE Wayne Young
3.9 RT Juan Bergman

[Mistwood]

Duds:
1.5 QB Madison - definitely, maybe not a complete dud but not worthy of his spot
1.19 QB Arsenault - same reasoning too high, and his INT is too low for being drafted that high

Studs:
3.1 DE Young - he would have been mine 6 picks later but I couldn't take him at the top of the 2nd
3.7 CB Gieb - was my fallback pick for losing Young, should be a very good corner for a 3rd rounder - and it worked out because I needed a corner more than another DE

[Heelfan71]

QB Madison is a 16/61 after camp. At least from my scout.

[Mistwood]

QB Madison is a 16/61 after camp. At least from my scout.

Like I said, he's not a complete dud, just not worthy of the #5 spot, he's going to take a long time to mature starting that low (16 current).

[Sgt Tomorrow]

1.19 QB Dixon Arseneault
2.20 FL Phil Alston

My fault on Alston... for giving a shit about certain jackasses complaints....

I drafted from work without the bars in front of me...
Nobody to blame but me, but being brand new I wasn't aware of which opinions counted and hurt my team because of it....
Growing pains...

Additionally the Monsters lost the overall #3 pick in the draft that went to the wrong team..... it's been a bad offseason for the monsters