1st Rd scouting

[irabowman]

For those that would I have taken 2 first rd draftees please report how your scouts see these 2 men. I just want to see how big a difference if any scouts have on players Pre- Training Camp please. Thanks, Ira

Pick 1.2 RB Turner Motor City
Pick 1.31 LT Krippler Waco

For me they scouted out 51/76 & 30/61

[BradZ]

For those that would I have taken 2 first rd draftees please report how your scouts see these 2 men. I just want to see how big a difference if any scouts have on players Pre- Training Camp please. Thanks, Ira

Pick 1.2 RB Turner Motor City
Pick 1.31 LT Krippler Waco

For me they scouted out 51/76 & 30/61

From Columbus

Turner 52/78
Kripper 31/65

[Cory]

I've got Turner at 51/76 and Kripper at 30/61.

[Aston]

52/78 (CLB)
51/76 (MEM)
51/76 (BOS)
51/76 (LVS)

31/65 (CLB)
30/60 (BOS)
30/61 (MEM)
30/61 (LVS)

[Gauss]

52/79 Turner
31/66 Kripper

[Guest]

51/76 Turner
30/61 Kripper

One thing: don't assume that all players have the same amount of masking applied. Maybe the players with more masking have more varied scout reports.

[irabowman]

51/76 Turner
30/61 Kripper

One thing: don't assume that all players have the same amount of masking applied. Maybe the players with more masking have more varied scout reports.

Kind of reason I chose a early & Late 1st rd. Maybe I should of chosen 2 player in 3rd or 4th rd but don't know who I would of chosen.

[Guest]

I have T in USFL who shows 40 future rated while the league scout has him 50. I have seen bigger differences than that, too. Worst thing is he is creeping so I have a feeling he is better than 40 rated (which is why I have kept him). If that's true then the crappy league scout has a better read on the guy that my decent team scout.

The good news is if you repeat the experiment enough times, the better scouts overall will give you the better reads. And the bad scouts can be off by larger margins.

The other thing to consider is in general, the human owners get the good scouts.

[Guest]

I got exactly what you did, Ira.

[Guest]

Waco preTC scouting grades:

2041 1.2 - Roosevelt Turner RB 52/79
2041 1.31 - K.C. Kripper LT 30/63

[IrishGuy65]

51/74 and 29/56

[Guest]

Turner 52/78
Kripper 31/65

[macroguru20]

Turner 51/75
Kripper 30/58