2036 OSFL Pro Bowl Awards - Results in!

[sawblade300]

Oh, all right. I'll take look.

[Guest]

That's why you got to make the tough calls! :)

Yeah, but I think I'll do 3 slots for WRs, 2 for RBs, 2 for TEs. That makes sense in that teams carry more WRs than TEs or RBs.

[Guest]

I had to go with Ohio River's WLB as the top DL. As a 3-4 WLB, he is functionally a DL and he was more extraordinary in that capacity than any DE or DT. Waco's Oliver Wunder posted pretty sweet numbers, especially for a DT.

The true LBs were tough to figure. I went with another Ohio River guy, their SLB, for his versatility. He was an effective blitzer, heavily involved in all phases of the game, and put up some of the best LB coverage numbers I saw. The other two guys were ILBs with extremely high tackle rates and they were decently competitive in coverage. It's hard for an ILB not to yield catches by the dozens, though.

I would argue that WLB is a 3-4 should be a LB and not a DL vote. While they are the pass rush in a 3-4 they are called on to do more things than a DE in a 4-3.

[Sharkn20]

Maybe if you do this during the play-offs the managers who are not qualified will get involve.

Just a FYI

[Guest]

I know, but the idea only occurred to me yesterday.

[irabowman]

I'll gladly vote next season as I don't know anything happened this last season.

[sawblade300]

Alright. I did it. I'll pay more attention this season. AH! Who am I kidding? No I won't, I only care about my team. Screw the rest of you guys and yours winning teams and championships. So overrated.

[Guest]

Amos Irwin was my #1 LB. I mean, 73 tackles, 9 sacks, 5 INT, and an amazing 86.8 PD% gets my vote every time. Obviously Quinn Smith's league leading 18.5 sacks has to get a vote. I took an ILB for the 3rd LB spot.

He had turf toe most of the season too, it was kind of a down year for him due to that.

[IrishGuy65]

He had turf toe most of the season too, it was kind of a down year for him due to that.

Well, with or without turf toe, the guy played his ass off for you guys last season. I love all around players. A guy that can do everything well is far more valuable than a guy that can only do one thing great. I'd love to have a team full of Amos Irwins!!!

[Guest]

OP has been updated with the winners. Congrats to those players/owners and thanks for playing along.

I decided to do a 1st and 2nd team and broke it down like so:

1st team - Near universal votes
2nd team - More than half total votes

Everyone else went as Honorable Mentions.

Raw data is attached in zip.

[Guest]

QB1 Brooklyn Hitmen - QB Albert "Wild Card" Garner
QB2 Phoenix Riders - QB Sammy "Slingn Sammy" Jennings
RB1 Yuma Aces - RB Terry "The Lock" Ness
FB1 Port City Steam - FB Otis Tomoyose
WR1 Brooklyn Hitmen - WR Van "Down by the river" Meier
WR2 Phoenix Riders - WR Stanley "Superman" Morrison
TE1 Utah Bees - TE Edwin Blades
TE2 Boston Irish - TE Nate "We Waited 20 Hour" Hartman
OL1 Pearl Harbour Defenders - G Leon Clevinger
OL2 Charlotte Sentinals - C Victor "Stay in yer" Lane
OL3 Charlotte Sentinals - G Horace Weaver
DL1 Kalispal Stags - DE Chester "Bad to the bone" Badillo
DL2 Boston Irish - DE Lincoln Cleaver
DL3 Port City Steam - DT Harold Everett
LB1 Ohio River Sharks - LB Quinn Smith
LB2 Brooklyn Hitmen - LB Gary "Leeroy" Jenkins
LB3 St. Paul Bandits - LB Justin McIntyre
DB1 Memphis Showboats - CB Conner Cannida
DB2 Dakota Totems - CB Leslie Parker
DB3 Anchorage Gladiators - SS Ralph Reid
PK1 Phoenix Riders - K Leslie Gardner
P1 Columbus Catfish - P Carlton Hotchkiss
KR1 Port City Steam - WR Brian Farley
ST1 Gainesville Gales - RB Allen Doyle
MVP Brooklyn Hitmen - WR Van "Down by the river" Meier

I would have voted for Waco players instead of the players with italics.

[Guest]

OP has been updated with the winners. Congrats to those players/owners and thanks for playing along.

I decided to do a 1st and 2nd team and broke it down like so:

1st team - Near universal votes
2nd team - More than half total votes

Everyone else went as Honorable Mentions.

Raw data is attached in zip.

Haha. Just saw this. Should have checked the thread. :P

[IrishGuy65]

This was fun and a great idea. I enjoyed it.

Congrats to the players and the coaching that put them in the position to win these awards.

[Guest]

I decided to do a 1st and 2nd team and broke it down like so:

1st team - Near universal votes
2nd team - More than half total votes

Everyone else went as Honorable Mentions.

I should elucidate here:

I did not follow the typical model of one or two people earning 1st or 2nd team per position. I thought it more interesting to simply go with the people who got the most points regardless of position.

This is how we ended up with no Kicker in the 1st team. I know, I know, the sky is falling with that one. It also explains why Van Meier was the only WR. There just wasn't enough consensus after him. That's more my fault than the voters, I think, in the I should've provided 3 slots for WRs.

At the end of the day, whether someone made 1st or 2nd team fell a bit on my own personal judgment of the votes. It had nothing to do with actual statistics on the field, but everything to do with how many voted for that position (ie. 7 people voted for QBs, 4 people for Punters, etc.), how many votes that player received and how many votes other players received.

[Aston]

This was fun and a great idea. I enjoyed it.

Congrats to the players and the coaching that put them in the position to win these awards.

Yeah, this was fun. Great stuff, garion! Thanks for doing this.