Share Your Ratings for 1st Rounders

[Guest]

It's fun to get feedback on the ratings for your draft picks through the eyes of other scouts. I've already gotten a few on Rowland and I feel fairly confident he'll rise. I figured we can all extend the service to each other here, so here's my list of my scout's opinion of all your first rounders. Feel free to share yours!

Scout abilities:

QB - VG
RB - G
WR/TE - VG
OL - Average
K - VG
DL - Average
LB - Average
DB - Average

1.1 Van Meier 52/81
1.2 C. Badillo 57/67
1.3 S. Morrison 52/78
1.4 K. Booker 27/57
1.5 M. Rowland 31/52
1.6 M. Ogden 48/67
1.7 R. Loukas 40/54
1.8 A. Frederick 47/69
1.9 C. Schoate 35/53
1.10 E. Sage 19/44
1.11 H. Emerson 51/73
1.12 A. Irwin 37/59
1.13 I. Manculich 29/51
1.14 E. Walker 44/78
1.15 B. Shields 38/89
1.16 A. Moss 31/71
1.17 J. Brooks 26/54
1.18 L. Freeman 39/74
1.19 C. Emmons 9/60
1.20 R. Thingvold 27/44
1.21 N. Meadows 27/63
1.22 L. Ellison 29/42
1.23 D. Carlisle 29/57
1.24 T. Loving 30/71
1.25 J. Hagen 39/53
1.26 M. Witt 33/54
1.27 R. Durham 43/64
1.28 E. Kyrouac 24/53
1.29 K. Hicks 38/56
1.30 C. Shaw 17/64
1.31 D. Fletcher 33/65
1.32 J. Carpenter 20/33

[Guest]

As a point of comparison, here is the opinion of the worst scout in the OSFL as to the ratings of all the first rounders. (parenthesis indicate variation from Foos' scout)


QB - Poor
RB - Average
WR - Fair
OL - Poor
K - Fair
DL - Fair
LB - Poor
DB - Poor

1.1 Van Meier 52/80 (0/-1)
1.2 C. Badillo 57/67 (0/0)
1.3 S. Morrison 51/77 (-1/-1)
1.4 K. Booker 28/58 (+1/+1)
1.5 M. Rowland 32/56 (+2/+4)
1.6 M. Ogden 48/67 (0/0)
1.7 R. Loukas 41/56 (+1/+2)
1.8 A. Frederick 45/69 (-2/0)
1.9 C. Schoate 35/53 (-10/0) wow!
1.10 E. Sage 19/48 (0/+4)
1.11 H. Emerson 50/72 (-1/-1)
1.12 A. Irwin 38/61 (+1/+2)
1.13 I. Manculich 29/51 (0/0)
1.14 E. Walker 44/78 (0/0)
1.15 B. Shields 37/89 (-1/0)
1.16 A. Moss 31/71 (0/0)
1.17 J. Brooks 26/54 (0/0)
1.18 L. Freeman 39/72 (0/-2)
1.19 C. Emmons 9/58 (0/-2)
1.20 R. Thingvold 27/45 (0/+1)
1.21 N. Meadows 27/61 (0/-2)
1.22 L. Ellison 30/44 (+1/+2)
1.23 D. Carlisle 29/56 (0/-1)
1.24 T. Loving 30/70 (0/-1)
1.25 J. Hagen 39/53 (0/0)
1.26 M. Witt 33/53 (0/-1)
1.27 R. Durham 43/64 (0/0)
1.28 E. Kyrouac 24/53 (0/0)
1.29 K. Hicks 36/56 (-2/0)
1.30 C. Shaw 17/63 (0/-1)
1.31 D. Fletcher 32/62 (-2/-2)
1.32 J. Carpenter 21/34 (1/1)

[Aston]

Hey, I remember Paul Marchion now. Totally forgot about his one-and-done stint here in Utah. "I just got a good receiver, so I should probably trade him away for a 3rd and he won't have five years left to play at a high level or anything."

I think Foos must have mistyped on Shoate, that's really weird.

Here's a tracker file (which doesn't have the 'after' camp numbers, of course) that contains ratings for all rookies (and everyone) from my scout.

<table cellspacing="1" cellpadding="1" border="1"><tr><td>QB</td><td>Very Good</td></tr><tr><td>RB</td><td>Very Good</td></tr><tr><td>WR</td><td>Fair</td></tr><tr><td>OL</td><td>Excellent</td></tr><tr><td>K/P</td><td>Average</td></tr><tr><td>DL</td><td>Very Good</td></tr><tr><td>LB</td><td>Very Good</td></tr><tr><td>DB</td><td>Very Good</td></tr><tr><td>YT</td><td>Average</td></tr></table>
^ for what that's worth...

[Guest]

Yup, I did mistype on Schoate! Should've been "35"!