Overall Ratings - Please Read

[Andrew]

Please discuss this and vote. You might want to hold off your vote until people state their case for both sides.

[Squint]

I'd love to see an overall star rating system implemented with the 1-20 attribute rating scale.

This would give us a more in-depth assessment of a player's attributes by our scouts, but still have the ambiguity of a 1-5 overall star rating.

[robster1225]

I 100% agree with HLewison.

[BruceM]

Can't vote since 1 - 20 isn't an option here. That's what I voted for in the rating scale poll.

Whatever rating system we use it should be the same for overall as the scale used. Not have one at 20 - 80 and the other at 2 - 8.

[Andrew]

Can't vote since 1 - 20 isn't an option here. That's what I voted for in the rating scale poll.

Whatever rating system we use it should be the same for overall as the scale used. Not have one at 20 - 80 and the other at 2 - 8.

Overall is either 20-80, or Stars (1-5). You don't have all the choices that the normal ratings have.

[BruceM]

Can't vote since 1 - 20 isn't an option here. That's what I voted for in the rating scale poll.

Whatever rating system we use it should be the same for overall as the scale used. Not have one at 20 - 80 and the other at 2 - 8.

Overall is either 20-80, or Stars (1-5). You don't have all the choices that the normal ratings have.

So then this has changed from 2006 and previous versions?

[Andrew]

So then this has changed from 2006 and previous versions?

Yes, in the fact that they re-added stars. 2006 was only 20-80 and I believe 6.5 was only Stars.

Are we talking about the same thing?

[BruceM]

Are we talking about the same thing?

I don't think so.

I know for a fact in 2006 you could set overall ratings and scale ratings to any of the choices available, 1-5, 2-8, 1-10, 1-20, 20-80, & 1-100.

[Andrew]

These are the ratings options for 2007:



And for 2006:



I'm talking about the Overall/Potential rating, in which the choices are 20-80 and Stars. This option definitely didn't exist in 2006.

[Andrew]

This vote has been pretty inconclusive so I'm going to stick with what we have now. 2-8 for ratings and 20-80 overall. However, I'm going to switch coaches ratings to 20-80 as well.