Originally posted by Jake
View Post
LADD should debut the highest. Top 50 for sure. In fact, he'll compete with the Catcher (SANTANA) as the Top Position Player from this draft on the day after the draft.
ADAME would be next. He's in a tier with the DWYER kid who was taken last. Top 75 for sure... maybe as high as high 40's. Those two are pretty interchangeable by the way this list seems to be calculated.
I think there are at least two other position players that fall in the mid-tier between LADD and ADAME/DWYER.
BERTRAND and RODRIGUEZ are on the high side of the Top 100 to me. I have 5 IFs in the Top 100... these two are #4-5 on the list. Though, to be fair, that group is really tight for me.
****
NOW.... taking off my "what I think the game/OSA/Top Prospects List will think of the draft" hat.... here's my personal take on these 4....
Ladd - Hometown kid goes to DC. Poor man's TJ Knudson type project. Quite poor though. He doesn't run quite as well. His defense isn't as good. And, even at full potential, he's only 80% of Knudson. That being said, he's got potential but a LONG way to go. The injuries would have scared me off this kid. You just can't develop if you're not playing. That being said, someone like this needs a team the manages the shit out of their minors. Perfect landing spot for him is a place like DC. If he ends up somewhere like Los Alamos, he's out of the universe by 22.
Adame - He's a Virginia type guy. His BLB OBP will be more in the .350 range which I don't love... but good lefty stick with wheels to burn. Wish he was a better defender (feeder league defensive stats tend to be misleading), but still think he has a great chance of a strong future in the BLB. Like the pick very much.
Bertrand - One of those weird guys who rode the bench for an entire season in the middle of his career (Sophomore year). I think he's too high here. One thing I've noticed in the last two versions of the game, far fewer 1B prospects in the draft. I think Bertrand is a 1B when push comes to shove. If he was a legit middle infielder, I think he's a good pick Top 10.... he's not.
Rodriguez - He's BLB ready. He'll play by the end of this year on the right team. Like Bertrand, I think he's a 1B/DH type or a really, really rough 3B. At 23, needs to go to a team that wants to play him almost immediately. Really like his upside.
Comment