BLB "What If..." #6

[Clay]

Better at this stage I would say.

I think his resume is better. Sure Scott has some cumulative stats that are higher... but... I think Chavez' resume already trumps Scott's.

[BradZ]

Call me crazy... call me biased.... Chavez is already > Geoff Scott

I don't see how anyone would argue any differently. Scott should have been one of the greats, but too many injuries in his younger years have brought him down a notch or two.

[Clay]

I don't see how anyone would argue any differently. Scott should have been one of the greats, but too many injuries in his younger years have brought him down a notch or two.

Exactly. Scott was the guy I wanted Chavez to be. Now Chavez is the guy that Scott should have been.

[BradZ]

Exactly. Scott was the guy I wanted Chavez to be. Now Chavez is the guy that Scott should have been.

Scott should have been a Colonial. He'd be one of the greatest players of all time. LH batter in that ballpark, Mid IF with power and one of the best eyes in the league. If he'd spent his prime years in that lineup I can't imagine the types of numbers he'd have put up . . . .provided he stayed healthy.

[Clay]

Scott should have been a Colonial. He'd be one of the greatest players of all time. LH batter in that ballpark, Mid IF with power and one of the best eyes in the league. If he'd spent his prime years in that lineup I can't imagine the types of numbers he'd have put up . . . .provided he stayed healthy.

We have the injuries set to OFF in VIR... just ask Diesel...

[BradZ]

We have the injuries set to OFF in VIR... just ask Diesel...

Well, come on. It's totally necessary for the good of the league. After Pancho missed an entire year with an injury you were totally justified in turning them off. We can't have once in a lifetime players being ruined by injury.

[Clay]

Well, come on. It's totally necessary for the good of the league. After Pancho missed an entire year with an injury you were totally justified in turning them off. We can't have once in a lifetime players being ruined by injury.

Thank you!!! I'm glad someone gets it!

[Delandis]

just ask Diesel...

Well Jistic says its true and you know the saying.....

[Carlos]

But Chavez plays short and Scott plays 2B. So, uh...what?


Sent from my mobile device.

[BradZ]

But Chavez plays short and Scott plays 2B. So, uh...what?


Sent from my mobile device.

Scott can play SS with the best of them. He has a DUI or two at the position.

[Carlos]

Does he? Wow I totally missed that. Like I said "uneducated". Just went off the dome.

Wait!

That doesn't matter. I didn't put Scott over Chavez. Chavez plays short. If there's beef on an all-time spot then that beef should be for choosing Sanchez.



Sent from my mobile device.

[BradZ]

Does he? Wow I totally missed that. Like I said "uneducated". Just went off the dome.



Sent from my mobile device.

Perhaps you need a collaborator for your book.

[Carlos]

Read my edit. My thoughts still stand.

I'm waiting for someone to provide evidence that all-time, Chavez is better than Sanchez.


Sent from my mobile device.

[Clay]

But Chavez plays short and Scott plays 2B. So, uh...what?


Sent from my mobile device.

He played more games at 2B (he said without looking)

[liquidcrash]

Read my edit. My thoughts still stand.

I'm waiting for someone to provide evidence that all-time, Chavez is better than Sanchez.


Sent from my mobile device.

Jose Sanchez?

Well his VORP is already higher. His peak is much, much, much, much higher. Like, by a lot. The margin isn't close.